Author: Tom Williams

Was a Marine brig as nasty and torturous as that depicted in Kenneth H. Brown’s play? Brown spent 30 days in the brig for going AWOL so maybe his memory was a tad tainted? However, as depicted in the Mary-Arrchie production, The Brig surly was hell on earth. The inmates here constantly screamed at (there was so much shouting, I’d advise bring ear plugs). This play features dedicated work from the entire cast.

We meet Franklin as she enlisted in the Union Army just before the first major battle as a man – the persona that she adapted earlier to both escape her abusive father and to find employment as a traveling book salesman. She had plenty of practice living as a man show fooling her fellow soldiers wasn’t very hard for her especially when physical exams were not given in those days. We see how Franklin was just one of the “boys.” among the soldiers of the Michigan regiment. She bravely served and was well liked by her mates.

I think for Big Fish to be a hit on Broadway, it needs to consider casting stronger singers; play Edward with more warmth, charm and heart. I’d also cut some scenes and songs to give the show a more streamlined flow. The ending needs to be re-thought and tightened. The eye-popping visuals and the costumes and choreography are the best elements of the show. Now, re-focus the book and make Edward a loveable rascal and this show could swim with other Broadway big fish. There is making of a show here.

While Donnelly’s drama tries to depict the tepid attempts by the British school system to educate even the losers, it wonders of into a sexy no-man’s land with the Zoe-Maz and Zoe-Daniel encounters. It seems that the teachers and students in this school have a predilection toward acting on their sexual desires. But when the Harry tries to bribe Zoe into changing a report about Mickey’s conduct, the tone of the play changes into a series of cover-your-ass exchanges and actions.