Tom Williams

Set in 1931 at the Kit Kat Club of Weimar Berlin, Cabaret.featuring the rich John Kander score with Fred Ebb’s biting lyrics, Cabaret is a multi-layered musical of decadence and desperation. Based on Christopher Isherwood’s novel, Berlin Stories, Cabaret from its 1966 Broadway opening (winner of 8 Tony’s) and the 1972 film (winner of 8 Oscars) has been mounted often to varying levels of success. In the 2014 Marriott Theatre production (now playing), director David H. bell and Choreographer Matt Raftery have made several questionable choices. it seems that they wanted to somewhat re-imagine Cabaret when audiences have grown to expect a mixture of the stage and film versions of the 1966 & 1972 productions.

When an upwardly mobile African-American couple wants to buy a home in an all white neighborhood of 1950’s Boston, they pay a struggling Irish family to “ghost-buy” a house on their behalf. Fifty-two years later, the Irish family wants “their” house back. Moving across two eras, Luck of the Irish explores our legacy of racial and class issues and the long held secrets that tie two families and one house together.

Reminiscent of Bruce Norris’ Clybourne Park, Luck of the Irish deals with an affluent black family, Lucy (Mildred Marie Langford) and Dr. Rex Taylor (Andre Teamer) who pay cash with a $1500 bonus to a poor Irish family with six children to the Taylor’s can live in a fine all-white neighborhood

The play’s action comes to a complete halt when Brian and Sheila enact all the events as how Joe came into the world handicapped and what the couple did to try to get something done to help little Joe. In this series of enacted events, Vance Smith deftly and quite comically impersonated fastidious British doctors as well as a goofy German doctor. Smith demonstrated his versatile acting skills. His part is extremely over written but in Vance Smith’s hands Brian becomes a most impressive fellow. You’d be hard pressed to see a stronger acting performance. Smith makes his verbose character tolerable.

As problematic as the work’s premise is, I am confused by the tone. With the wildly over-played British accents and having women play males soldiers with an over-the-top manner and the prisoners, especially the women, I’m not sure if Our Country’s Good is suppose to be a comedy or a parody or a satire? But with so much cruelty toward the prisoners by most of the soldiers, it is hard to see the piece as more than melodrama.