REVIEWSREVIEWS BYTheatre ReviewsTom Williams

West Side Story

Book by Arthur LaurentsWest Side Story 2011 National Tour

Music by Leonard Bernstein

Lyrics by Stephen Sondheim

Directed by David Saint

Choreographed by Joey McKneely

Musical Direction by Patrick Vaccariello

National Tour 2011

At the Palace Theatre, Chicago

Zesty Bernstein score sounds and dances up a storm

It has been decades since I’ve seen a Equity National Tour of West Side Story but I have seen several worthy regional theatre productions of WST including a terrific Marriott Theatre remounting a few years ago.  So it was with great anticipation that I welcomed the 2011 National Tour  of the classic 1957 Broadway gem – West Side Story to the Palace Theatre. Director David Saint and choreographer Joey McKneely’s cast was long on dance acumen, energy and  spirit. From the opening “Prologue,” we realize that West Side Story is a polished dance show that artfully blends Jerome Robbins’ original choreography into a spirited high-energy dance spectacular. We see innovative jumps, twirls and synchronized movement with hints of classic ballet, modern jazz with some Latino movement and fight twists added. These dances bring Leonard Bernstein’s pulsating jazz/Latino music to life. This cast, while reduced by 1/3, still knocks out the intricate Robbins’ choreography  with thrilling abandonment.

West Side Story 2011 National Tour

We meet both gangs – The Jets and the Puerto Rican The Sharks as each act out their rivalry through dance in numbers like “Dance at the Gym,  “Cool” and “America.” But as amazing as the dancers were, I was totally disappointed with the voices of all the principal characters. In his introductory song, “Something’s Coming” Kyle Harris’ Tony lack of vocal range showed up. Harris – a curly black-haired  man looks more Puerto Rican than Polish – a real problem since Tony is the Polish.

West Side Story 2011 National TourWest Side Story 2011 National Tour

Ali Ewoldt’s Maria had a weak voice (Where is Marni Nixon when we need her?) also and her duets with Harris’ Tony fell below the standard in “Tonight” and “One Hand, One Heart.” You would think the producers would find actors who have the proper look and vocal ability to land Sondheim’s legendary tunes! These two did not.

West Side Story 2011 National TourWest Side Story 2011 National Tour

My other problem was the baffling translation of several of the songs and long stretches of dialogue from English into Spanish. Why? This has not been needed as the show never seemed to need it before since 1957, so why now? It added nothing and it hurt several of the songs such as ” I Feel Pretty” and the haunting “A Boy Like That”/”I have a Love.” My generation knows the lyrics so no problem with us but several younger audience members told me that they were lost as to what those songs really meant. Too bad since Sondehim’s satiric, hard-edge lyrics got muddled with a needless translation into Spanish.

West Side Story 2011 National Tour

With all that being said, let me state that this National Tour is still a most worthy, even breathtaking theatrical event. Bernstein’s music and the Robbins’ inspired dances are so exquisite that this production is a terrific show to introduce teens  to the magic of classical Broadway musicals. West Side Story certainly captures the angry voice of urban youths in the 1950’s. Much of that angst still resonates today. But in this high energy production – dance and a heart-throbbing score dominate. And that is all that is needed sometimes.


Tom Williams

Talk Theatre in Chicago podcast

Date Reviewed: July 20, 2011

For more info on West Side Story page on

At the Cadillac Palace Theatre, 151 W. Randolph, Chicago, tickets $32 – $95,, Tuesdays at 7:30 pm, Wednesdays ar 2 & 7:30 pm, Thursdays & Fridays at 7:30 pm, Saturdays at 2 & 8 pm, Sundays at 2 pm, running time is 2 hours, 30 minutes with intermission, through August 14, 2011


3 thoughts on “West Side Story

  • I agree the Spanish was NOT needed. It seems that some folks can’t stop changing shows that have proven to be enduring.

  • Saw it Friday night. I must say the person playing Tony was very weak. The person playing Maria was outstanding Friday night. When they had their duets, they lacked luster, mostly to Tony’s inability to sing a straight tone (vibrato was as wide as the grand canyon) and that is when he was even able to stay on pitch. The dancers were all great. When the males san Officer Krupke, I was waiting for a train wreck, but they were surprisingly on pitch. The male who played the top fighter for the Jets was a great dancer and then when he opened his mouth I was surprised to hear he had a great voice. Probably would have been better in the role of Tony than the actor who played him.

  • Very descriptive article, I loved that bit.
    Will there be a part 2?

Comments are closed.